Kathleen Kennedy Townsend has a very well thought-out response to Sarah Palin's misguided criticisms of John F Kennedy's speech he gave in 1960 to the Greater Houston Ministerial Association. In it, Kathleen writes:
[Kennedy] challenged the ministers - and the country - to judge him, a Catholic presidential candidate, by his views rather than his faith. "Contrary to common newspaper usage, I am not the Catholic candidate for president," Kennedy said. "I am the Democratic Party's candidate for president who happens also to be a Catholic."
She goes on to tell us why Kennedy believed [rightly] that there should be a seperation between church and state. And concludes:
The United States is one of the most vibrant religious countries on Earth precisely because of its religious freedom. When power and faith are entwined, faith loses. Power tends to obfuscate, corrupt and focus on temporal rather than eternal purposes.
What Kennedy doesn't mention - and it is worth pointing out - is that Palin's history is also lacking. When Kennedy gave that speech he was still on the campaign trail and there were real concerns among many Christians [in this case Democrats in the south] who were wary of a Catholic becoming President. Some felt he might put his Catholic beliefs ahead of his beliefs in the Constitution. Or worse that he would consult the Pope about political matters.
At the time Catholocism was viewed in much more negative terms than it is today. And so John F Kennedy wanted to reassure these Christians [and every voter in America] that his religious beliefs were not going to drive his governance of the country.
But note he was not attempting - as Palin suggests - to run away from his faith. Instead he was trying to put his faith in the context of exactly where it had always been in American politics; seperated from the state. He said in the speech that he wanted to be judged as a politican and an American rather than as a Catholic who might succumb to some of the controversial views that the church had had in the past. And in this respect he was absolutely right to reassure voters of exactly where he stood as someone running for the highest office in the land.
It's a brilliant speech that hits one common sense point after another. Criticising is odd at best and, in the case of Palin's views, sheer ignorance of what Kennedy was actually saying.
The speech can be read and seen here.
Recent Comments